Netiquette · Download · News · Gallery · Homepage · DSSR Manual · G-quadruplexes · DSSR-Jmol · DSSR-PyMOL · DSSR Licensing · Video Overview· RNA Covers

Author Topic: Finding base pair having a overlap  (Read 6730 times)

Offline guchan

  • with-posts
  • *
  • Posts: 4
    • View Profile
Finding base pair having a overlap
« on: December 02, 2013, 04:16:14 am »
Hello Xiang-jun:
    I'am using 3DNA and meet a problem that there is a "missing pair". According to the definition of a "base pair" in 3DNA, the two bases in one pair should not have a overlap, which is not documented in misc_3dna.par. 
    If I want to force the overlapped bases to a "pair", what should I do? (Your suggestion in a topic is making manual changes of the  .inp file and the steps can be found in Simulation part. But I didn't find the steps,  could you please give me a hyperlink?)
    Thank you very much!

Chan Gu

Offline xiangjun

  • Administrator
  • with-posts
  • *****
  • Posts: 1640
    • View Profile
    • 3DNA homepage
Re: Finding base pair having a overlap
« Reply #1 on: December 02, 2013, 07:18:04 am »
Could you please post a specific example? The defaults in 3DNA/DSSR have been set the way they are for solid reasons, and work well for the vast majority of cases.

Xiang-Jun

Offline guchan

  • with-posts
  • *
  • Posts: 4
    • View Profile
Re: Finding base pair having a overlap
« Reply #2 on: December 02, 2013, 10:13:04 pm »
Hi Xiang-jun,
    Thanks for your reply. My system should have 30 base pairs:

200_f1.pdb
200_f1.out
    2         # duplex
   30         # number of base-pairs
    1    1    # explicit bp numbering/hetero atoms
    1   60  0 #    1 | ....>-:...1_:[DA5]a-**--t[DT3]:..60_:-<....  8.75  4.01 60.74 12.24 19.80
    2   59  0 #    2 | ....>-:...2_:[.RU]U-----A[.DA]:..59_:-<....  0.43  0.13 29.17  9.18 -2.86
    3   58  0 #    3 | ....>-:...3_:[.DA]A-----U[.RU]:..58_:-<....  0.86  0.78 14.86  9.15 -1.84
    4   57  0 #    4 | ....>-:...4_:[.RU]U-----A[.DA]:..57_:-<....  0.53  0.08 22.83  9.11 -1.18
    5   56  0 #    5 | ....>-:...5_:[.DA]A-----U[.RU]:..56_:-<....  1.00  0.71 17.87  9.37 -1.68
    6   55  0 #    6 | ....>-:...6_:[.RU]U-----A[.DA]:..55_:-<....  1.15  0.03 21.96  9.32 -2.68
    7   54  0 #    7 | ....>-:...7_:[.DA]A-----U[.RU]:..54_:-<....  0.88  0.35 24.57  9.55 -2.20
    8   53  0 #    8 | ....>-:...8_:[.RU]U-----A[.DA]:..53_:-<....  0.61  0.28 18.93  9.14 -2.87
    9   52  0 #    9 | ....>-:...9_:[.DA]A-----U[.RU]:..52_:-<....  0.82  0.37 26.23  9.46 -2.14
   10   51  0 #   10 | ....>-:..10_:[.RU]U-----A[.DA]:..51_:-<....  0.95  0.91 22.73  9.20 -1.10
   11   50  0 #   11 | ....>-:..11_:[.DA]A-----U[.RU]:..50_:-<....  0.90  0.11 19.12  9.17 -2.93
   12   49  0 #   12 | ....>-:..12_:[.RU]U-----A[.DA]:..49_:-<....  0.43  0.10 11.85  9.30 -1.77
   13   48  0 #   13 | ....>-:..13_:[.DA]A-----U[.RU]:..48_:-<....  0.37  0.36 26.80  9.17 -2.57
   14   47  0 #   14 | ....>-:..14_:[.RU]U-----A[.DA]:..47_:-<....  0.64  0.15 27.80  9.22 -2.66
   15   46  0 #   15 | ....>-:..15_:[.DA]A-----U[.RU]:..46_:-<....  0.68  0.20  2.20  9.31 -3.81
   16   45  0 #   16 | ....>-:..16_:[.RU]U-----A[.DA]:..45_:-<....  1.35  0.97 10.04  9.51 -1.20
   17   44  0 #   17 | ....>-:..17_:[.DA]A-----U[.RU]:..44_:-<....  0.86  0.83 27.72  9.06 -1.08
   18   43  0 #   18 | ....>-:..18_:[.RU]U-----A[.DA]:..43_:-<....  0.11  0.05 24.73  9.23 -3.55
   19   42  0 #   19 | ....>-:..19_:[.DA]A-----U[.RU]:..42_:-<....  0.86  0.69 19.68  9.13  0.22
   20   41  0 #   20 | ....>-:..20_:[.RU]U-----A[.DA]:..41_:-<....  0.86  0.56 25.33  9.45 -1.76
   21   40  0 #   21 | ....>-:..21_:[.DA]A-----U[.RU]:..40_:-<....  0.41  0.07 11.48  9.44 -3.87
   22   39  0 #   22 | ....>-:..22_:[.RU]U-----A[.DA]:..39_:-<....  0.54  0.52 16.31  9.45 -2.60
   23   38  0 #   23 | ....>-:..23_:[.DA]A-----U[.RU]:..38_:-<....  0.46  0.02 22.40  9.16 -3.38
   24   37  0 #   24 | ....>-:..24_:[.RU]U-----A[.DA]:..37_:-<....  0.49  0.36 20.01  9.14 -2.79
   25   36  0 #   25 | ....>-:..25_:[.DA]A-----U[.RU]:..36_:-<....  1.09  0.84  6.19  9.45 -1.93
   26   35  0 #   26 | ....>-:..26_:[.RU]U-----A[.DA]:..35_:-<....  0.41  0.07 18.96  9.28 -3.51
   27   34  0 #   27 | ....>-:..27_:[.DA]A-----U[.RU]:..34_:-<....  0.81  0.57 17.84  9.08 -2.16
   28   33  0 #   28 | ....>-:..28_:[.RU]U-----A[.DA]:..33_:-<....  0.83  0.27 11.33  9.65 -3.07
   29   32  0 #   29 | ....>-:..29_:[.DA]A-**+-U[.RU]:..32_:-<....  3.04  1.58 16.90 11.00  7.05
   30   31  0 #   30 | ....>-:..30_:[DT3]t-**--a[DA5]:..31_:-<.... 12.19  1.99 34.61  9.46 16.89
##### Base-pair criteria used:    30.00     0.00    20.00    30.00    90.00     0.00    20.00 [ O N]
##### 3 non-Watson-Crick base-pairs, and 1 helix (0 isolated bps)
##### Helix #1 (30): 1 - 30


However, due to the overlap, the first pair sometime missed:

11_f1.pdb
11_f1.out
    2         # duplex
   29         # number of base-pairs
    1    1    # explicit bp numbering/hetero atoms
    2   59  0 #    1 | ....>-:...2_:[.RU]U-----A[.DA]:..59_:-<....  1.88  1.82 46.49  8.64  2.83
    3   58  0 #    2 | ....>-:...3_:[.DA]A-----U[.RU]:..58_:-<....  0.95  0.91 23.98  9.27 -1.02
    4   57  0 #    3 | ....>-:...4_:[.RU]U-----A[.DA]:..57_:-<....  0.64  0.00 20.86  9.50 -3.31
    5   56  0 #    4 | ....>-:...5_:[.DA]A-----U[.RU]:..56_:-<....  0.65  0.32 14.91  9.56 -2.97
    6   55  0 #    5 | ....>-:...6_:[.RU]U-----A[.DA]:..55_:-<....  0.25  0.19 11.95  9.40 -3.78
    7   54  0 #    6 | ....>-:...7_:[.DA]A-----U[.RU]:..54_:-<....  0.40  0.21 16.46  9.53 -3.36
    8   53  0 #    7 | ....>-:...8_:[.RU]U-----A[.DA]:..53_:-<....  0.20  0.16 14.72  9.14 -3.74
    9   52  0 #    8 | ....>-:...9_:[.DA]A-----U[.RU]:..52_:-<....  0.13  0.05 24.32  9.25 -3.56
   10   51  0 #    9 | ....>-:..10_:[.RU]U-----A[.DA]:..51_:-<....  0.66  0.21 31.04  9.52 -2.37
   11   50  0 #   10 | ....>-:..11_:[.DA]A-----U[.RU]:..50_:-<....  0.34  0.15 24.63  9.36 -3.13
   12   49  0 #   11 | ....>-:..12_:[.RU]U-----A[.DA]:..49_:-<....  0.45  0.06 34.52  9.16 -0.70
   13   48  0 #   12 | ....>-:..13_:[.DA]A-----U[.RU]:..48_:-<....  0.52  0.21 27.79  9.35 -2.67
   14   47  0 #   13 | ....>-:..14_:[.RU]U-----A[.DA]:..47_:-<....  0.28  0.05 27.74  9.29 -3.23
   15   46  0 #   14 | ....>-:..15_:[.DA]A-----U[.RU]:..46_:-<....  0.26  0.21 21.63  9.17 -3.23
   16   45  0 #   15 | ....>-:..16_:[.RU]U-----A[.DA]:..45_:-<....  0.84  0.37  9.27  9.61 -2.96
   17   44  0 #   16 | ....>-:..17_:[.DA]A-----U[.RU]:..44_:-<....  0.80  0.63 28.07  9.40 -1.55
   18   43  0 #   17 | ....>-:..18_:[.RU]U-----A[.DA]:..43_:-<....  0.66  0.61 28.18  9.33 -1.72
   19   42  0 #   18 | ....>-:..19_:[.DA]A-----U[.RU]:..42_:-<....  0.69  0.07  9.82  9.36 -3.68
   20   41  0 #   19 | ....>-:..20_:[.RU]U-----A[.DA]:..41_:-<....  0.73  0.73  7.95  9.50 -2.40
   21   40  0 #   20 | ....>-:..21_:[.DA]A-----U[.RU]:..40_:-<....  0.67  0.14 29.09  9.59 -2.60
   22   39  0 #   21 | ....>-:..22_:[.RU]U-----A[.DA]:..39_:-<....  0.29  0.18 23.75  9.01 -3.17
   23   38  0 #   22 | ....>-:..23_:[.DA]A-----U[.RU]:..38_:-<....  0.42  0.04 19.41  9.46 -3.53
   24   37  0 #   23 | ....>-:..24_:[.RU]U-----A[.DA]:..37_:-<....  0.86  0.18 11.37  9.66 -3.21
   25   36  0 #   24 | ....>-:..25_:[.DA]A-----U[.RU]:..36_:-<....  0.47  0.14 11.46  9.31 -3.69
   26   35  0 #   25 | ....>-:..26_:[.RU]U-----A[.DA]:..35_:-<....  0.19  0.15 15.49  9.06 -3.75
   27   34  0 #   26 | ....>-:..27_:[.DA]A-----U[.RU]:..34_:-<....  0.32  0.17 25.31  9.56 -3.08
   28   33  0 #   27 | ....>-:..28_:[.RU]U-----A[.DA]:..33_:-<....  0.81  0.62 18.75  9.34 -2.01
   29   32  0 #   28 | ....>-:..29_:[.DA]A-----U[.RU]:..32_:-<....  0.64  0.36 24.17  9.25 -0.43
   30   31  0 #   29 | ....>-:..30_:[DT3]t-----a[DA5]:..31_:-<....  1.12  0.99 41.81  9.43  0.19
##### Base-pair criteria used:    30.00     0.00    20.00    30.00    90.00     0.00    20.00 [ O N]
##### 0 non-Watson-Crick base-pairs, and 1 helix (0 isolated bps)
##### Helix #1 (29): 1 - 29


So the question is how to force the first overlaped pair to a "pair"?

The attachments include : two pdb files that in normal situation(normal.pdb) and having a overlap(overlap.pdb), respectively, and a picture showing the overlap.

Many thanks!

Chan Gu

Offline xiangjun

  • Administrator
  • with-posts
  • *****
  • Posts: 1640
    • View Profile
    • 3DNA homepage
Re: Finding base pair having a overlap
« Reply #3 on: December 03, 2013, 12:00:38 am »
Hi Chan Gu,

Thanks for posting two PDB files and an image, which help clarify the issues. Firstly, I'd say that you are certainly on the extreme side for some bp-defining parameters (e.g., H-bond distance cutoff of 20 Å). I am glad to see that 'find_pair' is still working properly, without giving many extraneous bps. Secondly, to force a pair between DA5/1 and DT3/60, you could simply edit the default output file as below:
From:
    2         # duplex
   29         # number of base-pairs
    1    1    # explicit bp numbering/hetero atoms
    2   59  0 #    1 | ....>-:...2_:[.RU]U-----A[.DA]:..59_:-<....  1.88  1.82 46.49  8.64  2.83

****************************************************************************
To:
    2         # duplex
   30         # number of base-pairs
    1    1    # explicit bp numbering/hetero atoms
    1   60
    2   59  0 #    1 | ....>-:...2_:[.RU]U-----A[.DA]:..59_:-<....  1.88  1.82 46.49  8.64  2.83

As shown clearly in your attach image, DA5/1 and DT3/60 are stacking instead of pairing. In such extreme cases, 'find_pair' does not work as you'd expect, for solid reasons. Here certain manual editing is required, as illustrated above. I take this 'extra work' as an advantage since it reminds users to pay attentions to the abnormality.

If you are analyzing MD trajectories for an ensemble of similar structures, you do not need to run 'find_pair' for each model. See x3dna_ensemble analyze -h for further info.

HTH,

Xiang-Jun
« Last Edit: December 03, 2013, 12:02:46 am by xiangjun »

Offline guchan

  • with-posts
  • *
  • Posts: 4
    • View Profile
Re: Finding base pair having a overlap
« Reply #4 on: December 03, 2013, 02:21:24 am »
Hi xiang-jun,
   Thank you very much! I've tried your suggestion and it works. I did not use x3dna_ensemble for some reasons,  but I' ll certainly try it latter.

   Thanks again!

Chan Gu

 

Created and maintained by Dr. Xiang-Jun Lu [律祥俊] (xiangjun@x3dna.org)
The Bussemaker Laboratory at the Department of Biological Sciences, Columbia University.